As I mentioned in my review of Tokyo Babylon 1, I recently purchased first volumes of various newly-published English manga translations. This post will cover the first volume of Tsubasa: RESEVoir CHRoNiCLE and xxxHolic, two of the three (or four if you count X) series by CLAMP currently running in Japan. I’m reviewing these two manga together for two reasons. First, they are both published by Del Rey, a new entry into the manga publishing field, though not a new publisher by any means. Second, these series both cross over with each other, with some of the same events happening in both manga but from different viewpoints.
These are two of the first four manga published by Del Rey, and if these two volumes are indicative of the way they plan to publish in the future, then they will quickly become one of my favourite manga publishers. Both books have been done exceptionally well, with lovely quality printing, translated sound effects beside the original Japanese, honourifics left in with a detailed explanation of them at the beginning of the book and extensive notes at the end on other related CLAMP works, primarily Cardcaptor Sakura. The colour pages have been printed twice—once in colour at the beginning and then again in black and white at the start of the main body of the manga. I assume this is done to make it easier to produce later versions without the pages in colour.
For those who have read or watched Cardcaptor Sakura, many of the characters of Tsubasa will be very familiar, as they include Sakura, Syaoran (the spelling used in this book) and Tomoyo. The versions of these characters are not, however, the same versions from CCS but are instead their equivalents in alternate worlds.
In this world, Sakura is the princess of the Kingdom of Clow, and Syaoran is her childhood friend, a commoner from another country who is in charge of an archaeological dig in Clow. After an act of sabotage by a mysterious figure that occurs at the dig, Sakura’s heart/memories have been spread across multiple words, and Syaoran must travel to the Space-Time Witch in order to be able to travel between the worlds to rescue all of her memories and save her life. Tsubasa also includes alternate versions of characters from other manga, including Chobits, Magic Knigths Rayearth and X, plus a quick cameo by Miyuki-chan.
xxxHolic makes it clear that the world(s) that both it and Tsubasa take place in include both these alternate versions of these familiar characters and their “original” versions, at least for the CSS characters. The main two characters in xxxHolic are Yûko Ichihara, the Space-Time witch mentioned before, and Watanuki Kimihiro, a seemingly ordinary teenager who sees spirits. He has been tricked into working for Yûko, as payment for her granting his wish to no longer see spirits, which she will grant after she feels he has worked enough to earn it.
Some people have criticised the artwork in xxxHolic because it is very different from previous CLAMP artwork. Other than the colour pages, the artwork is completely black and white with no shading or screentones. Personally, I love the artwork, partially because it is so distinctive, and I find it just as attractive as more typical CLAMP art. The artwork in Tsubasa is also lovely, though the character designs are much more angular than their CSS counterparts, and it is strange seeing Tomoyo with such different eyes, and I found her the least recognisable of the characters “borrowed” from other series.
Both Tsubasa and xxxHolic can be read on their own, but they are more enjoyable if they are read together. I think they’d still be enjoyable even without much familiarity with Cardcaptor Sakura, as both stories are very different from CSS. Of the two, so far Tsubasa is the more dramatic and xxxHolic the more comedic, but things could and probably will change in future volumes, knowing CLAMP’s love of twists and surprises. Both are highly recommended, and I’m waiting impatiently for the next volumes to come out this autumn.