As most Doctor Who fans will already have heard, the Daleks will not be in the first series of the new Doctor Who because of breakdowns in negotiations with Terry Nation’s estate. (For those who don’t know, the late Terry Nation was the creator of the Daleks and his estate shares the rights to their use with the BBC.) Needless to say, loads of people, including myself, are disappointed in this announcement.
There’s been loads of speculation among fans as to how this will affect the new series, especially in its perception by the general public. Will the lack of Daleks turn off a non-Whovian from checking out the new series? After all, the Daleks are the most famous of Who monsters, and are a cultural icon in their own right. Does Doctor Who need the Daleks to succeed?
In my opinion, no. Doctor Who does not need the Daleks. Their lack may hurt the series a bit, especially as a Dalek episode would almost guarantee good ratings, but I think most people who were going to watch the new show will do so anyway, even without Daleks. After all, Doctor Who is more than just the Daleks, and people will still be looking forward to the new monsters a new series will bring, as well as any other old monsters that are revisited. Plus representatives of the BBC have stated that they will try renegotiating for their use in the second series, which is good news both for the Daleks and Doctor Who in general, as it indicates that the BBC is seriously considering a second series even before the first one has started filming.
For those who can’t wait until the second series for a possible reappearance of the Daleks, in the meanwhile check out the one-act play The Daleks Buy a Hotdog by Matt McIrvin.